Disclosure: WebFin is reader-supported. If you buy hosting through links on this page, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Commissions vary between providers and our ratings do not — here’s our full disclosure.
Hostinger and HostGator both renew at $10.99 a month. That is the same figure to the cent, which happens nowhere else across the fourteen plans we have priced. The same HostGator figures set against Newfold Digital’s Bluehost are in our Bluehost and HostGator comparison.
Therefore the entire difference between them is how long each holds its introductory rate. Hostinger holds $2.99 for 48 months and HostGator holds $3.75 for 36.
The Short Answer
Hostinger, 4.2 against 3.2, and the margin is smaller than the score suggests for the first three years.
However, HostGator answers the phone, gives 45 days to change your mind rather than 30, and belongs to a group that recently upgraded its sister brand and not this one.
Head to Head
| Hostinger Premium | HostGator Hatchling | |
|---|---|---|
| Advertised | $2.99/mo | $3.75/mo |
| Term for that price | 48 months | 36 months |
| Renews at | $10.99/mo | $10.99/mo |
| Three-year total | $107.64 | $135.00 |
| Six-year total | $407.28 | $530.64 |
| Refund window | 30 days | 45 days |
| Phone support | No | Yes |
| Email hosting | Included | Included |
| Owner | Private, ~30% PE-held | Newfold Digital |
| In our benchmark | 5th on Business, 28th on Premium | not covered |
| Our score | 4.2 | 3.2 |
The Gap Freezes at Month 48
Most price comparisons on this site either widen forever or cross over. This one does something else.
In practice, twelve months costs $35.88 against $45.00, a gap of $9.12. Three years: $107.64 against $135.00, a gap of $27.36. Four years: $143.52 against $266.88, a gap of $123.36.
Then it stops entirely. At six years the gap is still $123.36, because from month 49 onward both plans charge the identical $10.99 and neither pulls ahead.
Of course, that shape is worth understanding before choosing. Months 37 to 48 add $96 of the $123 total gap, because HostGator has renewed by then and Hostinger has not. After that you are paying the same rate at both — the full field is here.
Where the Evidence Is Uneven
⚠️ We should say plainly that these two hosts are not documented equally.
For instance, the benchmarking project we cite throughout ranks Hostinger Business 5th of 34 hosts at 223 milliseconds globally, and Hostinger Premium 28th at 495 milliseconds. The plan priced here is Premium. It does not publish figures for HostGator at all. The same HostGator figures against a Cloudways server are in our Cloudways and HostGator comparison.
Meanwhile, what exists for HostGator is smaller studies. One twelve-month test measured 487 milliseconds from New York with timeouts under 100 concurrent users, and recorded 99.908 percent uptime, which works out to roughly eight hours a year. The same HostGator figures against Kinsta are in our Kinsta and HostGator comparison.
That asymmetry is not HostGator’s fault and it is not evidence against it. It does mean one column of this comparison rests on thinner ground than the other.
The Sister Brand Problem
Besides, HostGator belongs to Newfold Digital, which also owns Bluehost along with six further brands named in its own boilerplate.
In November 2025 Newfold announced Bluehost was moving to Oracle Cloud Infrastructure. HostGator was not named in that announcement, and no comparable migration has been announced for it since.
By contrast, Hostinger is privately held with a private equity firm holding around 30 percent by its own account, owns its infrastructure, and has no sister brands competing on a shortlist.
Neither structure is hidden. The difference is that one of them means a shortlist containing HostGator and Bluehost contains one company twice — we traced the paper trail.
What HostGator Does Better
Two things, and both are real.
First, it answers a published telephone line around the clock. Hostinger runs chat and email, opening with an AI assistant that transfers you on request.
Second, its refund window runs 45 days against 30, which matters most when migrating an existing site because migration and DNS propagation consume the first week of any trial — we set out that timing separately.
What Renews Separately
In practice, HostGator describes its weekly backups as courtesy copies rather than a guaranteed service. Daily backups require CodeGuard from $2.99 a month, SiteLock appears pre-selected at checkout from $1.99, and a dedicated IP runs $4.95.
Hostinger includes email hosting and WHOIS privacy rather than selling them, and adds a free domain on annual plans.
In truth, neither host is unusual here. The difference is how many boxes you have to uncheck.
Winners by Category
Three-year cost: Hostinger, by $27.36.
Cost after month 48: Hostinger, by $123.36, frozen.
Renewal rate: a draw at $10.99 exactly.
Speed: Hostinger, though the comparison is uneven.
Refund window: HostGator, by fifteen days.
Support: HostGator, by a telephone line.
Included features: Hostinger, by selling fewer of them.
Ownership clarity: Hostinger, by having no sister brands.
When to Choose HostGator Instead
You want a phone number. That argument has decided several comparisons on this site and it decides this one too if it applies to you.
You are migrating an existing site and want six weeks rather than four to be sure.
You are buying for three years or less and the $27.36 difference does not move you. Inside that window the two plans are closer than the scores imply.
How We Research
Every figure comes from the two underlying reviews, where each is attributed to a named source with its window. Where our usual benchmark covers one host and not the other, we say so rather than presenting both columns as equally documented. We run no tests of our own.
Our criteria are on our About page. The long versions are in our Hostinger review and our HostGator review.
Frequently Asked Questions
Hostinger, by $27.36 over three years and $123.36 from month 48 onward. Both renew at $10.99 a month, so the difference comes entirely from Hostinger holding its introductory rate for 48 months against HostGator’s 36.
Per month, yes. Both renew at exactly $10.99. The accumulated gap stops growing at month 48 and stays at $123.36 for as long as you keep both plans.
Hostinger by the available evidence, though the comparison is uneven. One benchmark ranks Hostinger 5th of 34 hosts at a 351 millisecond global average and does not cover HostGator. A smaller study measured HostGator at 487 milliseconds from New York.
It answers a published telephone line around the clock, which Hostinger does not. Its refund window also runs 45 days against Hostinger’s 30, which is useful when migrating an existing site.
HostGator belongs to Newfold Digital, which also owns Bluehost, Network Solutions and five further brands. Hostinger is privately held in Vilnius, with a private equity firm holding around 30 percent by its own account.
The Verdict
Hostinger, 4.2 against 3.2, and the gap between those numbers comes mostly from evidence rather than from measured failure.
Choose Hostinger for the longer introductory term, the included email and privacy, and the ranking in a benchmark that covers it.
Choose HostGator if you need a telephone line or a longer refund window, and accept that the host you are buying is the sister brand that did not get the infrastructure upgrade.