Disclosure: WebFin is reader-supported. If you buy hosting through links on this page, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Commissions vary between providers and our ratings do not — here’s our full disclosure.
GoDaddy vs HostGator pits two budget hosts against each other, although only GoDaddy clearly publishes phone support around the clock. HostGator Hatchling costs $135.00 across a 36-month term against $215.64 for GoDaddy Economy, and its 45-day refund window beats GoDaddy’s 30 days.
HostGator belongs to Newfold Digital, which bought it in 2021; GoDaddy is publicly listed. Our scores favor HostGator, at 3.2 against 2.7. This comparison shows why, and where GoDaddy still wins.
GoDaddy vs HostGator: The Short Answer
Pick HostGator for the lower three-year price and the longer refund window, then add daily backups. Pick GoDaddy if you want its managed WordPress plans, which measure well ahead of both hosts’ shared hosting.
Head to Head
| Criterion | GoDaddy Economy | HostGator Hatchling |
|---|---|---|
| Three-year total | $215.64 | $135.00 |
| Renewal | $11.99 list; $15.32 in the cart | $10.99 |
| Backups | Check the plan | Weekly as a courtesy; daily $35.88 a year |
| Uptime | 99.76% | 99.68% |
| Time to first byte | 751 ms | 1.23 s global |
| Support | Phone, 24/7 | Chat and tickets 24/7; phone disputed |
| Refund | 30 days | 45 days |
| Owner | Publicly listed | Newfold Digital (2021) |
| Our score | 2.7 | 3.2 |

HostGator Costs Less, Before Backups
HostGator Hatchling costs $3.75 a month on a 36-month term, which is $135.00, and renews at $10.99. GoDaddy Economy costs $5.99 a month on the same term, or $215.64.
However, add-ons narrow the gap. HostGator calls its weekly backups a courtesy, so daily CodeGuard backups at $35.88 a year bring three years to $242.64. GoDaddy’s Economy plan, meanwhile, charges $119.99 a year for SSL from year two, which takes it to $455.62.
| Host and plan | How it builds | 36-month total |
|---|---|---|
| ChemiCloud Starter, 36-month term | 36 prepaid months at $2.49 | $89.64 |
| InterServer Standard | 36 months at $2.50, price locked | $90.00 |
| DreamHost Launch, 48-month term | 36 of 48 prepaid months at $2.89 | $104.04 |
| Namecheap Stellar, 24-month term | 24 at $1.98, then 12 at $4.88 | $106.08 |
| Hostinger Premium, 48-month term | 36 of 48 prepaid months at $2.99 | $107.64 |
| HostGator Hatchling, 36-month term | 36 months at $3.75, renewal not reached | $135.00 |
| HostGator Hatchling, with daily backups | 36 at $3.75, plus CodeGuard at $35.88 a year | $242.64 |
| Bluehost Starter, 36-month term | 36 months at $3.99, renewal not reached | $143.64 |
| GoDaddy Economy, 36-month term | 36 months at $5.99, renewal not reached | $215.64 |
| GoDaddy Economy, with SSL from year two | 36 at $5.99, plus $119.99 in years two and three | $455.62 |
| Hostwinds Basic, annual | 12 at $4.54, then 24 at $6.99 | $222.24 |
| SiteGround StartUp, 24-month term | 24 at $2.99, then 12 at $14.99 | $251.64 |
| DreamHost Launch, annual | 12 at $2.89, then 24 at $10.99 | $298.44 |
| Scala Hosting Mini, annual | 12 at $2.95, then 24 at $11.95 | $322.20 |
| Bluehost Starter, 12-month term | 12 at $3.99, then 24 at $11.99 | $335.64 |
| IONOS Plus, annual | 12 at $1.00, then 24 at $14.00 | $348.00 |
| GreenGeeks Lite, 36-month prepay | 36 months at $2.95 | $106.20 |
| GreenGeeks Lite, annual | 12 at $2.95, then 24 at $13.95 | $370.20 |
| SiteGround StartUp, 12-month term | 12 at $2.99, then 24 at $17.99 | $467.64 |
| Cloudways, from | 36 months at $14.00, flat | $504.00 |
| A2 Hosting Turbo Boost, annual | 12 at $6.99, then 24 at $20.99 | $587.64 |
| Rocket.net Starter, annual | 12 at $25.00, then 24 at $30.00 | $1,020.00 |
| WP Engine Startup, annual | 12 at $27.00, then 24 at $35.00 | $1,164.00 |
| Liquid Web managed VPS | 36 months at $33.00 | $1,188.00 |
| Kinsta Starter | 36 months at $35.00, flat | $1,260.00 |
| InMotion Core, 36-month term | 36 months at $3.19, renewal not reached | $114.84 |
| InMotion Launch, 36-month term | 36 months at $4.99, renewal not reached | $179.64 |
| Cloudways email, five mailboxes, a month | 5 × $1.50 Rackspace / 5 × $1.99 Titan Pro | $7.50 / $9.95 |
| DreamHost Email, 5 mailboxes, annual | $1.67 × 5 × 12 | $100.20 a year |
| GoDaddy Economy, next 36-month term | Renewal shown in the cart at $15.32 a month | $551.63 |
| Google Workspace or Microsoft 365 middle plan, ten users | $14.00 a user × 10 × 12 months | $1,680 |
| Hostinger Business Starter, five mailboxes, one year after the trial | 5 × $1.59 × 12 | $95.40 |
| Hostinger VPS KVM 1, 24-month term | 24 at $6.49, then 12 at $11.99 | $299.64 |
| Hostinger VPS KVM 2, 24-month term | 24 at $8.99, then 12 at $14.99 | $395.64 |
| Hostinger Website Builder Premium, 48-month term | 36 of 48 prepaid months at $2.99 | $107.64 |
| IONOS VPS L, 1-year term | 6 at $10.00, then 30 at $15.00 | $510.00 |
| IONOS VPS M, 1-year term | 6 at $6.00, then 30 at $8.00 | $276.00 |
| IONOS VPS XS | 36 at $2.00 | $72.00 |
| Suite middle plan, five users | $14.00 a user × 5, a month | $70.00 |
| Zoho Mail Lite, five users | $1.00 a user × 5, a month | $5.00 |
A Close Race on the Named Record
In fact, neither host measures well on shared hosting. GoDaddy’s shared plans show 751 ms to first byte and 99.76% uptime between November 2025 and June 2026, with a load test that did not complete.
HostGator’s 2026 review shows a 1.23-second global time to first byte, 99.68% uptime and 762 ms at 500 users. However, a September 2026 update ranked HostGator’s hardware joint-highest in the field after its move to Oracle, so newer tests may favor it.

GoDaddy’s Managed WordPress Changes the Picture
For a WordPress site, however, GoDaddy’s managed plans are a different product. Hostingstep measured them at 344 ms to first byte, well ahead of either host’s shared hosting, as our GoDaddy WordPress guide explains.
By contrast, HostGator’s WordPress route runs on its shared plans, as our HostGator WordPress guide covers.
Refunds, Support and Owners
HostGator’s 45-day refund window covers all plans, excluding domains and add-ons, while GoDaddy gives 30 days. Both also answer by phone around the clock. Our guide on canceling hosting and getting a refund covers both.
HostGator belongs to Newfold Digital, which also owns Bluehost, as our page on who owns Bluehost explains. If you are leaving a brand in that group, our guide on moving away from an EIG brand helps.
Before You Switch Between Them
Moving between GoDaddy and HostGator takes only an afternoon if you plan it. First of all, take a full copy, as our guide to website backup services explains, then follow our guide on migrating web hosting.
Check the checkout before you pay, since both hosts add extras, as our guide on avoiding checkout upsells shows. Our guide to choosing a hosting plan also helps you pick the tier. Our page on what web hosting really costs then covers the full budget.
Where Each One Is Weakest
GoDaddy is weakest on price: the highest three-year total here and an SSL charge from year two. HostGator is weakest on backups, which it does not guarantee, and on a slow global time to first byte in its 2026 review.
Winners by Category
Three-year cost: HostGator, at $135.00 against $215.64; Refunds: HostGator, at 45 days; Uptime: GoDaddy, narrowly; WordPress: GoDaddy, on its managed plans; Overall: HostGator, at 3.2 against 2.7.
When to Choose GoDaddy Instead
Choose GoDaddy for a WordPress site on its managed plans, or if you already keep your domains there. For stores, our guides to GoDaddy WooCommerce and HostGator WooCommerce compare the store routes.
Our renewal price guide shows how both compare with other budget hosts.

In addition, these guides may help: HostGator vs WP Engine and HostGator vs Hostwinds. Related reading also includes GoDaddy for Drupal.
Correction, 12 October 2026: we no longer describe HostGator’s phone support as round-the-clock, since Newfold’s support policy excludes Hatchling plans and 2026 users report trouble reaching a person by phone.
In addition, these guides go further on the topic: GoDaddy vs Hostwinds and GoDaddy vs Liquid Web.
Similarly, these guides may be useful next: GoDaddy vs InMotion Hosting and GoDaddy vs GreenGeeks.
How We Research
We run no tests. Performance figures come from Hostingstep’s 2026 benchmarks and its September 2026 update, each with its window. Prices, add-ons and refunds come from our TablePress tables and GoDaddy’s hosting page, read in October 2026.
Ownership comes from Newfold’s press releases and GoDaddy’s public filings. The criteria behind our scores are on our about page.
GoDaddy vs HostGator FAQ
HostGator: $135.00 across 36 months against $215.64 for GoDaddy Economy, before backups and SSL.
HostGator, with 45 days on all plans against GoDaddy’s 30 days; both exclude domains.
On shared hosting, GoDaddy measured 751 ms against HostGator’s 1.23-second global figure, though HostGator upgraded its hardware in 2026.
Newfold Digital, since 2021. GoDaddy is a separate, publicly listed company.
HostGator, at 3.2 against 2.7 for GoDaddy.
The Verdict
HostGator wins GoDaddy vs HostGator on our scores, with a lower three-year price and a longer refund window. Add daily backups, since its weekly ones are not guaranteed.
GoDaddy remains the better choice for one case: a WordPress site on its managed plans, which measure far ahead of both hosts’ shared hosting.
